Can we develop hindsight before we need it?
By Bukky Gray
Last week, we had the privilege of sharing our Signal or Story? the workplace judgement game, at the CASE Europe Annual Conference (CEAC) 2026. It prompted a fascinating conversation about how we interpret behaviour, make decisions and navigate the unwritten rules of working life.
During the session, we explored two scenarios. Waning Purpose examined a colleague whose motivation and sense of purpose appeared to be fading while Misaligned Expectations explored what happens when people believe they have agreed on something, only to discover they have very different understandings of what success looks like.
The game offers four actions: Wait, Adjust, Name or Involve and participants can only pick one action. Workplace decisions are rarely this linear. We don’t always make one clear choice and move on. We wait, then adjust, perhaps involve others, and eventually name something we should have addressed much earlier. Each decision changes the circumstances in which we operate. Only afterwards do we see how those choices add up. They say hindsight is 20/20, but what if we could develop some of that hindsight before the consequences unfold? We’re not talking fortune telling, but rather something far easier (or harder, depending on the person!): becoming more conscious of our assumptions, the perspectives we’re missing and the trade-offs we’re making.
The game itself is a jumping off point into rich discussion. Participants reflected on how much they underestimate the influence of their working environment. Like the proverbial frog in slowly warming water, we adapt so gradually that we barely notice ourselves changing. We become more cautious, stop asking certain questions, accept behaviours we once challenged, or start making decisions based on what we believe the organisation expects of us.
At what point does adapting to our environment become losing sight of our own values?
That led to another uncomfortable question for the room: Why do people who were frustrated by certain management behaviours sometimes reproduce those very behaviours when they become managers themselves?
Perhaps the pressures they once questioned now feel reasonable because they are the ones carrying the responsibility. Maybe the environment has remained the same, but their position within it has changed. Or, without realising it, they have absorbed the very norms they once resisted.
This is where values, emotional intelligence and reflection become important. Not as abstract leadership qualities, but practical ways of recognising when our judgement is shape-shifted by pressure, habit or assumptions about other people. The ability to distinguish what we have observed from the story we have constructed around it is especially important.
This isn’t about there being a right or wrong decision. Very rarely do we have the privilege of a black-and-white perspective. Empathy at work is not about always choosing the kindest or most comfortable response. It’s about understanding people and circumstances more accurately, recognising that every action has a trade-off, and making those choices with our eyes open.
Because the decisions we make today do more than resolve the immediate situation. Over time, they shape our relationships, our behaviour and the culture we become part of.
What signals are you noticing in your organisation, and what stories have people begun to build around them?
If you’re curious about the signals and stories shaping your workplace, and want to examine what they reveal about your culture, leadership and everyday decisions, give us a shout. We’d love to explore them with you.